The Holdegur are The Rapture Cycle versions of The Carnal, appearing briefly in chapter two of Rapture: The Cockroach Metamorphosis. Hunger appeared as a giant, "ground-shaking" serpent and attacked Jordan Dooling first via constriction and destroying the ground around him, but was killed. Lust appeared as as a striped feline "swifter than sword" and attacked Jordan second, alluring him whilst it attacked, which failed, leading it to its death. Panic appeared as a black mammoth with rusted metal tusks which attacked Jordan last, making him charge at him with reckless abandon, but Jordan regained control and slayed it. It appeared later in the chapter apparently unharmed, chasing Jordan and the Tour Guide up a mountain at an inappropriate time.